On October 21, 2026, according to news reports, the Justice Department, acting for the Education Department, filed agreements to drop two of the government's appeals of the June 30, 2026 rulings that vacated the Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF) employer rule, and on October 26 Michigan's attorney general, one of 22 attorneys general who sued, said the administration had dropped its appeal in the states' case the week before. The rule would have let the Secretary of Education remove an employer from PSLF for a “substantial illegal purpose” starting July 1, 2026; with the appeals withdrawn, the vacatur stands. For borrowers, that test cannot cut off a month of credit, and the 120-payment count runs on the rules already in place; the Department's September 22, 2026 Federal Register notice pulls the employer attestation off the PSLF form.
The trap is the printed text. The eCFR version of 34 CFR 685.219, marked up to date as of October 23, 2026, still carries the vacated scheme: an exclusion inside the qualifying-employer definition, a six-part definition of substantial illegal purpose at paragraph (b)(30), and a credit cutoff at paragraph (c)(4). The regulation and the court record now describe two different rules.
What the Government Dropped, Date by Date
The rule was published as the Federal Register final rule on the William D. Ford Federal Direct Loan Program (October 31, 2025), 90 FR 48966 through 49002. Its DATES line opens: “These regulations are effective July 1, 2026.” It then points to the implementation-date discussion, where the preamble ties that date to section 482(c) of the Higher Education Act, which requires title IV regulations to be final by November 1 before the award year they apply to; October 31 cleared that deadline by one day.
The Education Department press release on the PSLF final rule (October 30, 2025) traced the rule to Executive Order 14235, signed March 7, 2025, and a proposed rule of August 18, 2025 that drew nearly 14,000 comments.
The rule did not reach its first effective day. The Department's own account is in the Federal Register notice on the PSLF & TEPSLF Certification and Application form, 91 FR 60119 (September 22, 2026): “On Tuesday, June 30, 2026, a Federal judge vacated the rule; one day prior to the rule becoming effective.” According to news accounts of the dockets, the October 21 agreements gave no reason and left each side to pay its own fees; five days later came the Michigan statement on the 22-state case.
Vacated in Court, Still Printed in the eCFR
The eCFR text of 34 CFR 685.219, the Public Service Loan Forgiveness Program regulation, is marked up to date as of October 23, 2026. Its paragraph (b) still defines 35 terms, including substantial illegal purpose at (b)(30) and violating State law at (b)(34). As read for this post, the page showed no editorial note about the court order, and the section's source note ends at 91 FR 23897, May 1, 2026, before the vacatur.
The qualifying-employer definition at (b)(27) has two halves. Part (i) lists five types: (A) a United States-based Federal, State, local, or Tribal government organization, including the Armed Forces and the National Guard; (B) a public child or family service agency; (C) a 501(c)(3) organization exempt from tax under Section 501(a); (D) a Tribal college or university; and (E) a nonprofit providing a non-governmental public service that is not a business organized for profit, a labor union, or a partisan political organization. Part (ii) is the vacated addition: the term “Does not include organizations that engage in activities such that they have a substantial illegal purpose, as defined in this section.”
Paragraph (b)(30) has six items: (i) aiding or abetting violations of 8 U.S.C. 1325 or other Federal immigration laws; (ii) supporting terrorism, including support for cartels designated as Foreign Terrorist Organizations, or violence to obstruct or influence Federal Government policy; (iii) chemical and surgical castration or mutilation of children in violation of Federal or State law; (iv) trafficking children to another State for emancipation from their lawful parents in violation of Federal or State law; (v) a pattern of aiding and abetting illegal discrimination; and (vi) a pattern of violating State laws, which (b)(34) limits to a final, non-default State court judgment for trespassing, disorderly conduct, public nuisance, vandalism, or obstruction of highways.
Under (h)(1), the Secretary would decide by a preponderance of the evidence, after notice and opportunity to respond, “that a qualifying employer has engaged on or after July 1, 2026, in illegal activities such that it has a substantial illegal purpose by considering the materiality of any illegal activities or actions as described in paragraph (b)(30) of this section.” Three things would be presumed conclusive evidence of (b)(30) activity: (i) a final State or Federal court judgment; (ii) a guilty or nolo contendere plea; and (iii) a settlement that includes an admission. Paragraph (h)(2) does not authorize a finding based on the employer or its employees exercising First Amendment or other constitutional rights.
Which text does the Department follow? Its September 22 notice answers on the form a borrower actually files: “The Department is now removing the attestation from the PSLF form in order to comply with the court order.” The next sentence: “No other changes have been made at this time.” The form tracks the court order; the compiled regulation still tracks the October 31, 2025 rule, and it will until the Federal Register publishes an amendment removing paragraph (b)(30).
The 120 Count Runs on the Older Text
The dismissed appeals left the borrower side of 34 CFR 685.219(c)(1) untouched. Its three conditions: (i) the borrower is not in default on the loan when forgiveness is requested; (ii) the borrower works full-time for a qualifying employer, or serves full-time in AmeriCorps or the Peace Corps, at two moments, (A) “When the borrower satisfied the 120 monthly payments described under paragraph (c)(1)(iii) of this section; and” (B) “At the time the borrower applies for forgiveness under paragraph (e) of this section; and” (iii) the borrower “Satisfies the equivalent of 120 monthly payments after October 1, 2007, as described in paragraph (c)(2) of this section, on eligible Direct loans.”
Full-time has three routes at (b)(11): (A) an average of at least 30 hours per week in the period certified; (B) at least 30 hours per week across a contract of at least 8 months in a 12-month period, as for teachers and professors; or (C) for non-tenure track instructors, each credit or contact hour taught per week multiplied by at least 3.35.
A month counts under 34 CFR 685.219(c)(2) through six branches: (i) paying at least the full scheduled amount; (ii) paying it in installments; (iii) on an income-driven plan, paying ahead no further than the next annual recertification; (iv) on a 10-year standard plan, paying ahead no further than the lesser of 12 months or the borrower's next submission; (v) eight kinds of deferment or forbearance, except while enrolled in the Repayment Assistance Plan; and (vi) full-time employment with a qualifying employer “at any point during the month for which the payment is credited.”
The vacated rule would have added one step: an employer attestation on the form, under penalty of perjury, of no substantial-illegal-purpose activity on or after July 1, 2026. That is the piece the Department is removing.
One Month, Two Readings of a Cutoff That Did Not Run
The borrower-side text still points at the vacated paragraph. The (c)(2) lead-in opens: “Except as provided in paragraph (c)(4) of this section, a borrower will be considered to have made monthly payments under paragraph (c)(1)(iii) of this section by” the six branches. After its July 1, 2026 start and its reference to the paragraph (h) standard, (c)(4) reads: “no payment shall be credited as a qualifying payment for any month subsequent to a determination that a qualifying employer engaged in activities enumerated in paragraph (b)(30) such that it has a substantial illegal purpose, as described in this section.”
Read beside (b)(27)(ii), the printed text supports two cutoffs. Reading one starts from the definition: an employer whose conduct began on or after July 1, 2026 fell outside it from the first month of that conduct, so branch (vi) fails for those months even before any determination. Reading two starts from (c)(4): credit stops only “for any month subsequent to a determination,” so earlier months stay credited, and so does the determination month itself, because branch (vi) needs full-time work at any point during the month.
The final rule's summary sided with reading two: borrowers keep full credit for work performed before the effective date of a determination. But that is preamble, while the definition is codified text. With the vacatur on June 30, 2026 and (c)(4) effective July 1, 2026 and (h)(1) reaching only conduct from that date, neither reading has had a month to work on.
Two Ten-Year Clocks
The borrower's clock is 120 qualifying monthly payments, measured against the 10-year standard plan. The qualifying repayment plan definition at (b)(28) has five items: (i) an income-driven plan; (ii) the 10-year standard plan or the consolidation standard plan with a 10-year term; (iii) except for the alternative repayment plan, any plan paying at least the 10-year standard amount; (iv) “An income-contingent repayment plan under § 685.209 for which a payment was received on or before June 30, 2028; or” (v) the Repayment Assistance Plan. For how that plan compares with income-based repayment, see TheWalletCompass on how RAP undercuts the IBR monthly payment.
The employer's clock is the vacated one, and it also runs ten years. Paragraph (j) says an organization that loses eligibility under (b)(27) “may regain eligibility to become a qualifying employer after” one of two routes: (1) 10 years from the Secretary's determination, followed by the organization certifying on a borrower's later application that the activities have stopped; or (2) “The Secretary approves a corrective action plan signed by the employer that includes” a certification that the activities stopped, a report on compliance controls, and any other terms the Secretary imposes.
Take a borrower with 60 qualifying payments made and 60 to go. A determination against that borrower's employer would have kept the employer out for 120 months under route (1), twice the borrower's remaining 60, while (c)(1)(ii)(B) still required a qualifying employer at the time of applying. Finishing would have meant changing jobs or waiting on a corrective action plan. The vacatur removes that collision.
What the Form Notice Tells a Borrower Now
The September 22 notice covers form 1845-0110, the PSLF and TEPSLF Certification and Application: “They are encouraged to submit this form annually but are only required to submit it at the point that they have reached the requisite 120 qualifying months of repayment.” The Department estimates 913,713 responses and 456,857 burden hours a year. Comments on the emergency revision were due October 22, 2026, the day after the first dismissals.
For a borrower who worked full-time for a qualifying employer from July through October 2026, certifying those months on the revised form, which drops the attestation, records that progress well before the 120th month.
The notice also prints two figures that disagree with the Department's other records. It names the executive order E.O. 14325, while the October 30, 2025 press release gives Executive Order 14235, and it dates the proposed rule August 18, 2026, while the press release gives August 18, 2025 and the same notice says comments closed September 17, 2025.
Numbers to Re-check
- 120 payments after October 1, 2007. Paragraph (c)(1)(iii) sets the count; (c)(1)(ii) checks qualifying employment when the 120th payment is satisfied and again at application.
- July 1, 2026 versus June 30, 2026. The printed effective date and the vacatur are one day apart, and the vacatur came first.
- October 23, 2026. The eCFR currency date on which paragraph (b)(30) still appeared, two days after the October 21 dismissals.
- 10 years. The vacated employer clock in paragraph (j), not the borrower's 120 payments.
- June 30, 2028. The last receipt date for an income-contingent payment under (b)(28)(iv).
- 14235, not 14325; 2025, not 2026. The executive order number and the proposed-rule year as the press release gives them.
Where This Doesn't Apply
Loans that are not eligible Direct loans sit outside the count in (c)(1)(iii), and a loan in default fails (c)(1)(i) when forgiveness is requested; for collection on defaulted federal student loans, see TheWalletCompass on student loan debt collection caps and floors. The rest of (b)(27) is intact, so a for-profit business, a labor union, or a partisan political organization stays outside type (E) regardless of the vacated test. Temporary Expanded PSLF shares the form but has its own rules, not covered here.
The vacatur ends this rule, not rulemaking on the subject; the Department could propose a new rule through the Federal Register.
What would invalidate this. The dismissal dates and the status of the 22-state appeal come from news accounts and the Michigan attorney general's October 26 statement; the appellate dockets were not read, and if the states' appeal is still open, the vacatur is less settled than described. The regulatory text quoted here comes from the eCFR, because the amendatory section of the October 31, 2025 final rule could not be retrieved, and a later Federal Register amendment would change what the code shows. The press release and the final rule's summary were read in summary form and are paraphrased, not quoted. The Federal Student Aid PSLF page did not load, so guidance posted there is not reflected.
Comments
Post a Comment