On Thursday, October 29, 2026, Binance said a security incident had affected $6.3 billion in customer assets, suspended withdrawals and deposits, and said it would cover the losses from its Secure Asset Fund for Users and company reserves. For a U.S. account holder, the tax question starts when coins move again, because a coin carried to another platform lands in a different category on the IRS’s new Form 1099-DA. The 2026 form must report cost basis only for a coin acquired after 2025 and held in the same custodial account until sold, so a transferred coin is a noncovered security whose basis box can be left blank.
Two more numbers read two ways: the tax code’s applicable date for digital assets is January 1, 2023, and the $10,000 and $600 figures limit the broker’s reporting, not the Form 1040 question. Each is traced below to IRS documents, 26 U.S.C. 6045(g)(3) and the Federal Register. None of this is advice to hold, move or sell a digital asset.
October 29: The Announcement and the Next Move
News reports on October 30 added that Binance’s initial investigation pointed to a compromised engineer’s laptop and that co-founder Yi He expected withdrawals to resume by Sunday, November 1. How a replacement credit would be taxed is outside this post. The IRS rules reach the next move, whether coins stay put, go to a personal wallet or another platform, or are swapped or sold, through two documents: the Form 1099-DA a broker sends and the digital asset question every Form 1040 filer answers.
Two Start Dates: Proceeds From 2025, Basis From 2026
The IRS fact sheet FS-2024-23 on the final broker regulations, updated November 7, 2025, gives both dates: “Brokers must report gross proceeds for transactions effected on or after January 1, 2025.” And: “Brokers must report basis on certain transactions effected on or after January 1, 2026.” Everything turns on “certain.” Proceeds are what came in; basis is what was paid.
The IRS Instructions for Form 1099-DA (2026) define it in a heading: “2026 and beyond—Mandatory reporting of gross proceeds for all digital assets, mandatory reporting of basis information for digital assets that are covered securities, and voluntary reporting of basis information for digital assets that are noncovered securities.” One 2026 sale can come with or without a cost figure, depending on when and how the coin entered the account.
Under Notice 2024-56, the fact sheet says, the IRS will not impose penalties for failing to file and furnish 2025 Forms 1099-DA if the broker “makes a good faith effort to file the Forms 1099-DA and furnish associated payee statements correctly and on time.” The notice’s backup withholding relief covers three cases: all 2025 transactions; 2026 transactions whose customer name and TIN match IRS records through the TIN-matching program; and, until further guidance, dispositions of digital assets for certain NFTs or real property, and certain payment-processor sales. Notice 2024-57, listed at the end, defers reporting for six transaction types.
The Code Says 2023. The Form Says After 2025.
The statute starts earlier. In the Office of the Law Revision Counsel text of 26 U.S.C. 6045, Returns of brokers, current through Public Law 119-124 of October 15, 2026, subsection (g)(3)(B) lists five kinds of specified security: stock (i), debt (ii), commodities where the Secretary finds basis reporting appropriate (iii), “any digital asset” (iv) and other instruments on the same finding (v). Subparagraph (D) defines the term as a digital representation of value recorded on a cryptographically secured distributed ledger or similar technology, “Except as otherwise provided by the Secretary.”
Subparagraph (C) sets four applicable dates: January 1, 2011 for corporate stock other than clause (ii) stock; January 1, 2012 for stock eligible for an average basis method under section 1012; then “January 1, 2023, in the case of any specified security which is a digital asset, and (iv) January 1, 2013, or such later date determined by the Secretary in the case of any other specified security.” Amendment notes on the page credit Public Law 117-58, section 80603(b)(1)(C), with the digital asset clause, added in 2021. The “such later date” wording is in clause (iv) only.
Subparagraph (A) then covers a specified security acquired on or after its date if it “(i) was acquired through a transaction in the account in which such security is held, or (ii) was transferred to such account from an account in which such security was a covered security, but only if the broker received a statement under section 6045A with respect to the transfer.” On those words, a coin bought in an exchange account in 2024 and still held there cleared the 2023 date.
The 2026 instructions draw the line later: for Form 1099-DA, a covered security is a digital asset acquired after 2025 for cash, stored-value cards, other digital assets or property or services whose disposition the broker must report, and “A digital asset is a covered security only if it was acquired in an account for which the broker provided custodial services and was held in that account until the broker effects the disposition of the digital asset.” Acquiring includes granting an option and entering into a forward contract. Coins bought from 2023 through 2025 are on the noncovered list.
The instructions cite Regulations section 1.6045-1. The fact sheet ties the final regulations to Federal Register document 2024-14004, and a Federal Register correction notice at 89 FR 66563, August 16, 2024, identifies that document as Treasury Decision 10000, published Tuesday, July 9, 2024 at page 56480 and “issued under sections 1001, 1012, 3406, 6045, 6045A, 6045B, 6050W, 6721, and 6722 of the Internal Revenue Code.” The corrections took effect September 9, 2024.
Five Ways to Be Noncovered, Including a Transfer
The instructions list five kinds of noncovered security: “Any digital asset that the broker did not provide custodial services for when it was acquired”; “A digital asset that was acquired before 2026”; “A digital asset that was transferred in to the broker providing custodial services”; a coin acquired by an exempt recipient or an exempt foreign person, which would not have been reportable when sold; and one for which Regulations section 1.6045-1(g)(4)(vi)(E) requires reporting, “certain securities owned by a foreign intermediary or flow-through entity.”
The third item is what a reopened withdrawal window sets in motion. A coin bought on one platform in March 2026, moved to a second platform that files Form 1099-DA and sold there in December is noncovered on the second platform’s form. The Code’s clause (ii) keeps a transferred security covered only if it was covered in the old account and the new broker received a section 6045A statement; item three mentions no statement.
A customer’s adequate, timely identification sets which units a sale used. Absent one, the receiving broker “generally must first report the sale of the earliest units of the digital asset purchased by the customer,” and it may date a purchase from customer-provided acquisition information. The instructions continue: “If you do not take customer-provided acquisition information into account for that purpose, treat digital assets transferred into the customer’s account as acquired as of the date and time of the transfer.” For that ordering, unless the broker uses that information, a long-held coin moved in this November counts as bought this November. The form adds boxes headed “Number of Units Transferred in” (12a) and “Transfer-in Date” (12b), and box 8 flags reliance on customer-provided acquisition information.
Box 1g and Box 9: Blank Is Not Zero
Box 1g, “Cost or Other Basis,” opens: “Enter the adjusted basis of any digital asset sold unless the digital asset is not a covered security and you check box 9 and choose not to complete box 1g. If you check box 9 and are not reporting basis, leave box 1g blank.” Box 9, “Check if Digital Asset Is a Noncovered Security,” begins: “You may check this box if reporting the sale of a noncovered security. Do not check this box if reporting the sale of a covered security. If you check this box, you do not have to complete boxes 1d, 1g, 1h, 1i, and 6, and you do not have to check box 2.”
By heading, those are 1d “Date Acquired,” 1h “Accrued Market Discount,” 1i “Wash Sale Loss Disallowed,” 6 “Gain or Loss” and 2 “Check if Basis Reported to IRS.” A noncovered coin can show proceeds in box 1f with no acquisition date, basis or gain. A blank box 1g is basis not reported, not zero; entering proceeds against a zero cost would make every dollar received a gain.
The missing figure rests on the owner’s records, kept wallet by wallet: the fact sheet describes Revenue Procedure 2024-28 as transitional guidance for allocating unused basis to the coins in each wallet or account as of January 1, 2025, as the final regulations require. On the next platform’s form, a moved coin’s cost appears only if that broker chooses to report it.
$10,000 and $600: Floors for the Broker’s Form
Three de minimis rules carry the dollar figures, each limiting what a broker must report. A qualifying stablecoin meets three conditions: it is “designed to track on a one-to-one basis a single convertible currency issued by a government or central bank (including the U.S. dollar)”; it uses an effective stabilization mechanism; and it is generally accepted as payment by persons other than the issuer.
The stablecoin rule reads: “A broker reporting under the optional reporting method for qualifying stablecoins is not required to report designated sales of qualifying stablecoins if the customer’s aggregate gross proceeds (after reduction for the allocable digital asset transaction costs) from all designated sales of qualifying stablecoins effected by that broker do not exceed $10,000 for the year.” It binds only a broker using that method; it counts only designated sales, meaning sales other than for digital assets that are not qualifying stablecoins, plus deliveries settling certain executory contracts; and it runs per broker, so sales split across two platforms are measured separately. Above $10,000, the instructions add, such a broker “must report a customer’s aggregate designated sale transactions for each type of qualifying stablecoin on a separate Form 1099-DA.”
The other two floors are $600: specified NFTs under their optional method, and a payment processor’s PDAP sales. Both are cliffs: past $600 a year, all NFT sales are reported; for PDAP: “However, if a customer’s PDAP sales exceed $600 for the year, all of that customer’s sales must be reported.” Sales excluded under the stablecoin and NFT methods are left out of that test.
Each rule governs the broker’s form, not the return; the Form 1040 question must be answered whether or not a Form 1099-DA arrives. TheWalletCompass on where payroll withholding starts traces another trigger set apart from the tax.
The Digital Asset Question After Withdrawals Reopen
The IRS Instructions for Form 1040 (2025) define digital assets as “any digital representations of value that are recorded on a cryptographically secured distributed ledger or any similar technology,” naming NFTs and virtual currencies “such as cryptocurrencies and stablecoins.” Filers check “Yes” if during 2025 they “(a) received (as a reward, award, or payment for property or services); or (b) sold, exchanged, or otherwise disposed of a digital asset (or any financial interest in any digital asset).” Sales this fall go on the 2026 return, whose instructions were not read.
Eight examples call for “Yes”: receipt as payment, as a reward or award, from mining, staking and similar activities, or from a hard fork; disposal for property or services; a trade for another digital asset; a sale; and any other disposal of a financial interest. Three actions alone generally do not: holding; transferring between wallets or accounts you own or control; and buying with U.S. or other real currency, including through platforms such as PayPal and Venmo. Then: “If you used a broker to effect the sale of a digital asset, your broker should send you Form 1099-DA. You must answer the digital asset question on Form 1040 whether or not you received a Form 1099-DA.”
So, on the 2025 wording, for the week after October 29: moving coins from an exchange account to the owner’s own wallet is, alone, a transfer; swapping a coin for a stablecoin is a trade, a “Yes” whatever any broker’s floor says; selling is a sale. The section adds: “Do not leave the question unanswered.”
Numbers to Re-check
- October 29, 2026; $6.3 billion. News-reported figures, not IRS figures.
- January 1, 2025. Gross proceeds reporting begins.
- After 2025. Basis reporting, covered securities only: acquired in a custodial account and held there until sold.
- January 1, 2023. The Code’s digital asset date in section 6045(g)(3)(C)(iii). Purchases from 2023 to 2025 are still noncovered on the 2026 form.
- Five noncovered categories. A transfer-in is the third.
- Box 1g blank, box 9 checked. Basis not reported, not zero.
- Boxes 12a, 12b and 8. Units transferred in, transfer-in date, reliance on customer-provided information.
- $10,000. Qualifying stablecoins, designated sales, per broker, optional method.
- $600 and $600. Specified NFTs and PDAP sales; going over either brings every such sale onto the form.
- Eight and three. Form 1040 “Yes” examples, and actions that alone generally do not require one.
- July 9, 2024; 89 FR 56480. Treasury Decision 10000. Corrections effective September 9, 2024.
Where This Doesn't Apply
- Decentralized and non-custodial platforms. The fact sheet says: “The final regulations do not include reporting requirements for brokers commonly known as decentralized or non-custodial brokers that do not take possession of the digital assets being sold or exchanged.”
- Notice 2024-57. Wrapping and unwrapping, liquidity provider transactions, staking, transactions described as lending or as short sales, and notional principal contracts need not be reported until further guidance, but “This reporting exception does not apply to rewards or other compensation earned by participants in these transactions.”
- Exempt recipients and exempt foreign persons. Their coins fall in the fourth noncovered category; their reporting is not traced here.
- Platforms that do not file Form 1099-DA for you. Whether any Binance entity must file for a U.S. customer is not answered here. The Form 1040 question applies either way.
- The hack loss itself. Theft-loss deductions and reimbursement credits turn on rules not read here. Bank-account unauthorized transfers follow separate rules; see TheWalletCompass on Regulation E loss limits.
- State income tax. Not covered.
What Would Invalidate This
The Binance facts come from news reports of October 30 and 31, 2026, and could change; whether withdrawals resumed on schedule was not confirmed. The preamble of Treasury Decision 10000, where any reason for the later acquisition date would appear, was not read, and Regulations section 1.6045-1 could not be retrieved, so the 2026 instructions stand in for it. Notices 2024-56 and 2024-57 and Revenue Procedure 2024-28 were read only through the fact sheet. Only the quoted passages of the 2026 Form 1099-DA instructions were read; a transfer rule elsewhere in them, including the box 12a and 12b instructions, could refine the transfer example. A revision of those instructions, or an amendment to section 6045 after Public Law 119-124, would change this reading.
Comments
Post a Comment